Islington vs Mayfield

Updated 2026-05-18

Side-by-side comparison of Islington and Mayfield in Newcastle — prices, growth, development pipeline, vibe, and signals.

Local take: Islington has more creative energy; Mayfield has better fundamentals and lower prices. Both rising.
BUY
Islington
BUY
Mayfield
72/100
Islington vibe
68/100
Mayfield vibe

Islington BUY

Median house $1.2M
Median unit $810k
Growth YoY +21.8%higher
Vibe score 72/100higher
Pattern Emerging creative precinct with edge
Trend rising
DAs in pipeline 0
Contamination sites 1

Mayfield BUY

Median house $1.1Mlower
Median unit $818k
Growth YoY +7.0%
Vibe score 68/100
Pattern Gentrification accelerating, main street transforming
Trend rising
DAs in pipeline 1more
Contamination sites 1

Development Pipeline

Islington has 0 development applications, while Mayfield has 1 for 37 units. A larger pipeline means more construction activity but also signals where developers see demand.

Price Comparison

Mayfield ($1.1M) is 9% cheaper than Islington ($1.2M) for houses.

Considering an address in Islington or Mayfield? Check the exact surroundings → Surroundings Reports from $29

Go deeper on any address

This comparison shows the suburb picture. Our Surroundings Report covers what's within 500m of YOUR specific address: development, contamination, noise, and more.

Get a Surroundings Report

Surroundings Reports from $29

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, Islington or Mayfield?

It depends on what you're looking for. Islington has a BUY signal and a vibe score of 72/100, while Mayfield has a BUY signal and a vibe score of 68/100. The best suburb for you depends on your priorities — enter any address to see the full surroundings picture.

What's the price difference between Islington and Mayfield?

Mayfield is $105k cheaper for houses ($1.1M vs $1.2M). Year-on-year growth is +21.8% in Islington and +7.0% in Mayfield.

Which has more development, Islington or Mayfield?

Islington has 0 development applications, while Mayfield has 1 (37 units). More development means future supply and construction activity — which can affect both livability and property values.